The Silence Tax: A Memoir, a Publisher, and What Both Are Really For
On September 4, 2026, HarperCollins India announced that it would publish Belonging: A Journey of Love by Sonia Gandhi on November 10. This is the same date as its worldwide release by Alfred A. Knopf in the United States. The announcement came exactly one week after Penguin Random House India issued a statement clarifying that it was not, in fact, the Indian publisher of the book, and that any suggestion it had decided against publishing because Sonia Gandhi had declined editorial changes did not "accurately reflect the circumstances." Representational Image Source: @ckmbsnl on X The careful grammar of that sentence deserves some attention. Penguin did not say the reports were wrong. It said they did not accurately reflect the circumstances. It said it was "willing and keen" to publish. It declined to disclose the details of its discussions, citing confidentiality. What it did not say, and what the publishing world noted, was what those circumstances actually we...