Posts

Showing posts with the label Democracy

What India’s Prime Minister Talks About When He Does Not Talk About Votes

Image
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi spoke for about fifteen hundred words in Pune on Tuesday afternoon. He did not use the words Election Commission, electoral rolls, opposition or protest. File Photo Via: PM NaMo on X By that evening Rahul Gandhi was on X counting the hours. “It’s been 24 hours since I challenged you, Modi ji,” the leader of the opposition wrote, renewing a proposal he had made the previous day for a face-to-face debate. Modi could pick the stage, the venue and the adjudicator — “you can even make Mohan Bhagwat ji the judge,” he offered, naming the head of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the ideological parent of the ruling party. The media would be there, and the country’s young people. Daro mat , he wrote. Don’t be afraid. He signed off wishing the PM a happy Diwali, with a rose in hand. Notably, the subject he named was not the electoral rolls. It was the accusation being made against him. Who is anti-national, Rahul Gandhi asked, and who has connections with fo...

Social Media Has Made Protesting Near Power Redundant, Delhi’s Police Chief Tells Top Court

Image
Delhi’s police commissioner has told India’s Supreme Court that the advent of technology and social media means the closeness of a protest site to the seat of government has “ceased to be relevant and has become redundant” — the reasoning behind stripping the capital of its best-known venue for dissent Image Via: @IndiaHistorypic/ Photo Division The affidavit, filed by Commissioner Anurag Kumar, defends the removal of Jantar Mantar from the list of designated protest sites, a decision taken weeks into a national agitation against the Chief Election Commissioner. Jantar Mantar, he argues, was never a site at all but a public road that “ought not to have been declared” one, and its designation was “contrary to public interest since the inception.” Three replacements have been named: Ramlila Maidan in central Delhi, CBD Ground in the east and Burari Ground in the north-west. The commissioner set out why. The venue hosts more than 1,300 protests a year but can safely hold about 1,500 ...

India’s Vote Row Is Now A Fight About Where To Have The Fight

Image
India’s finance minister has told the leader of the opposition that the venue he is demanding for a public debate with the Prime Minister already exists, and that he holds a seat in it File Photo Via: @nsitharaman on X Nirmala Sitharaman was publicly replying to LoP Rahul Gandhi, who had spent two days challenging PM Narendra Modi to a face-to-face argument about which side has connections to foreign powers, offering to let Modi choose the stage, the venue and the adjudicator. “Parliament, where you happen to be the LoP,” she wrote, using the abbreviation for Leader of the Opposition. Her argument was about conduct rather than about the electoral rolls at the centre of the dispute. “Demanding answers also carries an obligation to hear them,” she said, accusing Gandhi and the opposition alliance of walking out while ministers were responding to their allegations and of disrupting sittings until they were lost entirely. She asked him to bring specific allegations and evidence, sayin...

India’s Opposition Fills Ramlila Maidan But Not The Million It Promised

Image
India’s opposition alliance drew tens of thousands to a rally in the capital on Sunday demanding the removal of the country’s chief election commissioner, a turnout far below the million its organisers had promised but the broadest gathering of opposition leaders on one stage in years. Image Via: @INCIndia on X Delhi police had expected around 50,000 and put the working capacity of Ramlila Maidan at 30,000 to 40,000 once the stages and enclosures were up. Organisers had said ten lakh — a million — would come. The ruling party said 40 per cent of the ground stood empty and counted several thousand vacant chairs out of 28,000 by mid-afternoon. More than 3,000 police and 10,000 paramilitary personnel were deployed, with cameras covering the venue and a cordon to stop any movement towards the de-notified protest ground at Jantar Mantar. Leaders marched the final stretch from Connaught Place in open-top vehicles. On the platform were Rahul Gandhi, Sonia Gandhi, Mallikarjun Kharge, Pri...

India’s Opposition Rally Becomes A Fight Over Space In The Capital

Image
Three days before India’s opposition holds the largest rally of its campaign against the country’s election chief, the dispute surrounding it has stopped being only about electoral rolls. It has become an argument about who may gather in the capital, where, in what numbers, and at whose expense File Photo Via: @RahulGandhi on X The INDIA bloc meets at Ramlila Maidan on 1 November to demand the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over a nationwide revision of electoral rolls the opposition says removed voters improperly. Delhi Police have cleared the rally for 10am to 5pm, with conditions: high-definition cameras at every gate and across the seating, a dedicated control room with at least five monitors, drinking water and women’s toilets, volunteers for crowd control, nobody on the ground overnight, and no procession beyond the venue. That last condition is the significant one. Every road into Ramlila Maidan will be barricaded and manned to stop any march towa...

Speaker Birla Says Fresh Bid To Remove Election Chief Will Follow Rules

Image
The Speaker of India’s lower house said on Thursday that any fresh motion seeking the removal of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar would be examined under parliamentary rules, as the opposition prepares a third attempt to unseat him Image Via: @ombirlakota on X “If any fresh notice comes, we will see and examine it accordingly under rules and procedures,” Om Birla told reporters while responding to questions at a press conference. He said the process resembled that for removing a Supreme Court judge, and that in a democracy everyone had the right to express their views. Opposition parties have demanded Kumar’s resignation over the Election Commission’s nationwide revision of electoral rolls, in protests that have run through October. The campaign followed a report in The Indian Express that the two other election commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, had recorded objections at least fourteen times in ten months to decisions and orders connected with the rev...

What India’s October Agitation Settled And What It Left For November

Image
✍️ Written by Saket Suman The campaign that produced more than seven thousand detentions in Delhi in a single day and a finding of prima facie contempt against the authorities, was announced to the press on 30 September with the dates attached Representational image Source: @INCIndia on X The opposition alliance published its calendar stating dates for district marches from 2 to 8 October, a march to the Election Commission on the 6th, a rally in Delhi on 1 November. The Congress Working Committee had resolved a day earlier to demand the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner and the suspension of the nationwide revision of electoral rolls. Behind both lay a newspaper investigation reporting that two of the Commission’s three members had objected on record at least fourteen times in ten months. What followed is mostly on the court record now.  On 9 October the Supreme Court called the Delhi Police orders restricting public trans...

Defence Minister Says Delhi Protesters Seek A Bangladesh-Style Change Of Regime

Image
India’s defence minister said on Friday that some of those behind two weeks of protests over the country’s electoral rolls were seeking a change of regime on the Bangladeshi model and accused them of making young people instruments of what he called the politics of anarchy Representational Image Source: @rajnathsingh on X Speaking at a news conference in Lucknow, Rajnath Singh said one person had openly told a press conference that she drew inspiration for regime change from Bangladesh while another had spoken of bringing down the government. Their only agenda, he said, was to destroy democratic institutions and set the country alight. He was referring to remarks made this week. The student leader Neha Bora has reportedly said she is influenced by the movement that removed Sheikh Hasina from power in Bangladesh. The advocate Prashant Bhushan told a news conference on Thursday that a change of government was the declared aim, that this is the purpose of any opposition in a democracy...

‘We All Want Regime Change’: Two Words Reshape India’s Protest Row

Image
A phrase with a long and loaded history entered India’s street confrontation over electoral rolls on Thursday, when advocate Prashant Bhushan said a regime change was a democratic right and the ruling party said the remark proved the protests had never been about voter lists at all Representational Image Via: @DrMeenaJangid on X Speaking at a news conference in Delhi alongside the student leader Neha Bora and the youth organiser Abhijeet Dipke, he rejected the government’s characterisation of the campaign. “This government keeps on saying this is the opposition’s operation of regime change. We are only appealing to save the electoral democracy in this country,” he said. Then came the conditional, and then the assertion. “If such barbarism continues, there will definitely be a regime change. We all want a regime change. Is there anything wrong with that? Regime change is a democratic right of every citizen, and creating disaffection against the government is not an offence.” He s...

India’s Top Court Opens Multiple Fronts On Electoral Rolls And Policing Of Protests

Image
India’s Supreme Court issued notices on Thursday across a cluster of cases arising from nearly two weeks of protests over the country’s electoral rolls, and one of the petitioners said the court had indicated it may frame guidelines to protect women demonstrators and women journalists Representational Image Via: @INCIndia on X The court issued notice to the Election Commission and its commissioners on the opposition petition over the revision of electoral rolls.  Petitions concerning the police operation of 10 October were heard together. The advocate Shailendra Mani Tripathi, one of the petitioners, said the court had taken cognisance and indicated it intended to issue guidelines, particularly for women protesters and women journalists.  The Delhi High Court separately declined to restrain a protest called for Friday at Central Park in Connaught Place, on an application by a licensed street vendor who said his business would suffer. The court recorded an assurance from t...

India’s Supreme Court To Hear Demand For Election Commission’s Internal Records

Image
India’s Supreme Court is due to hear on Thursday an opposition petition seeking disclosure of the Election Commission’s internal files on a revision of electoral rolls that has allegedly removed about 130 million names Representational Image: @RahulGandhi on X The petition filed by Rahul Gandhi, the leader of the opposition in the lower house, and other opposition leaders, asks the court to order the release of the files, agendas, minutes, notings and objections recorded by the two election commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. It asks the court to examine those records to establish whether Chief Election Commissioner acted arbitrarily and unilaterally, and seeks an interim order suspending the revision while the case is decided.  The two commissioners are central to the dispute. The Indian Express reported earlier that they had raised concerns with the chief election commissioner at least 14 times over ten months about decisions on voter registration and deletion...

India’s Ruling Alliance Answers Protest With Ten Questions And A Charge Of Anarchy

Image
Two ministers from India’s ruling alliance challenged the opposition on Tuesday to answer ten questions over its campaign against the country’s electoral rolls and accused it of abandoning constitutional remedies for the street Image Source: @BJP4India on X Piyush Goyal of the Bharatiya Janata Party and Rajiv Ranjan Singh of the allied Janata Dal (United) spoke at the BJP’s headquarters, a day after eleven opposition leaders filed a petition in the Supreme Court and marched to the court demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Goyal invoked B R Ambedkar, who chaired the drafting committee of India’s constitution, paraphrasing his warning that abandoning constitutional methods when they are available is the grammar of anarchy. The Congress had never filed a sworn affidavit with the Election Commission setting out its allegations, Goyal said, and had filed no claims for inclusion or exclusion while the roll revision was under way. He asked why the party...

Eleven Opposition Leaders Petition India’s Supreme Court Over Electoral Roll Revision

Image
Eleven opposition leaders filed a petition in India’s Supreme Court on Monday evening against the Election Commission and its three members Image Source: @INCIndia on X The petition was lodged after the leaders marched to the court from central Delhi. It was recorded on the Supreme Court website on Monday evening. The petitioners are the leaders of the opposition in both houses of parliament, Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge; Akhilesh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party; Tejashwi Yadav of the Rashtriya Janata Dal; Supriya Sule of the Nationalist Congress Party (Sharadchandra Pawar); Sanjay Raut of Shiv Sena (UBT); Saugata Roy of the Trinamool Congress; D Raja of the Communist Party of India; M A Baby, general secretary of the Communist Party of India (Marxist); Mahua Majhi of the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha; and E T Mohammed Basheer of the Indian Union Muslim League. Rahul Gandhi and Kharge had written asking to meet Chief Justice Surya Kant on Monday afternoon to hand him a memorandum. He d...

FLASH — Indian Opposition Marches To Supreme Court Over Electoral Rolls

Opposition leaders including Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and Akhilesh Yadav are currently marching through central Delhi towards the Supreme Court, where the opposition bloc said it would file a petition over the revision of electoral rolls and demand the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Thousands had gathered in the heart of national capital as the march moved from Connaught Place. This comes after the Chief Justice declined to receive the leaders and told them to come to the court by petition instead.  This is a developing story. The details above are the best available at the time of filing and may change as events unfold. Crowd and detention figures are estimates reported and have not been independently verified. This report will be updated.

Protest Ground Near Parliament Closed As India’s Opposition Marches To Supreme Court

Image
Police removed Jantar Mantar as the Indian capital’s designated protest ground hours before opposition leaders began their march to the Supreme Court to file a petition over the revision of electoral rolls A standing order issued by Delhi Police de-notified the site, which sits a short distance from Parliament and has been the city’s permitted venue for demonstrations for decades. Three grounds were designated in its place. The order says the change follows recommendations by a committee set up by the union home ministry to examine alternative venues for citizens to exercise the right to demonstrate, and that revised procedures for the new sites will be issued separately. It partially modifies an order of April 2022. The announcement came hours after lawyers mentioned a petition in the Delhi High Court challenging the closure of Jantar Mantar to peaceful protest, telling the bench that no alternative site had been earmarked. The court listed the matter for Tuesday. It also gave police...

Sunday Brings More Detentions As Police Hold Delhi Against Protesters

Image
India’s Supreme Court sat on Sunday, outside its working week, and ordered the authorities to restore normal life in the capital and to ensure nobody was illegally detained for assembling peacefully. Representational Image Via: @SFI_CEC The court directed that Metro and railway services run normally, that internet facilities remain undisturbed as permitted by law and that people and traffic be allowed to move freely. It said lawyers must be able to work and recorded an assurance that neither lawyers nor journalists would be obstructed. Restrictions remained subject to the public order limits the constitution allows under Article 19. Police removed barricades outside the court the same day.  Three leaders of the Cockroach Janta Party were released after almost 24 hours in custody. An executive magistrate ordered that they commit no breach of the peace for a year. Police said a surety bond of 50,000 rupees had been furnished for good behaviour over that period. The three were...

Delhi Police Detain More Than 7,000 To Keep Protesters Off The Streets

Image
More than 7,000 people were taken into custody across the Indian capital on Saturday as an attempt to hold a rally demanding the chief election commissioner's resignation was shut down  Representational Image Source: @AiyarYamini on X  The operation ran ahead of the protest rather than in response to it. Policemen were reported picking people up from homes, streets and an airport gate hours before the announced start time, and the running total police gave reporters climbed through the afternoon from roughly a thousand to past three thousand and finally beyond seven. A case was expected to be registered over an alleged attack on police personnel too. Behind the day was the Cockroach Janta Party, which wants Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar to go. Police had rejected the application to gather at Jantar Mantar, the sanctioned protest ground a few hundred metres from Parliament, on the grounds that the organisers had not satisfied procedural requirements and that ...

Opposition Petitions The President As Delhi Locks Down For Saturday

Image
A delegation of Indian opposition leaders met President Droupadi Murmu on Friday to demand the resignation of the country's chief election commissioner Image Source: @INCIndia on X The memorandum set out four demands: that CEC Kumar resign and that a 2023 law granting the chief election commissioner and election commissioners lifelong immunity be repealed; that the ongoing revision of electoral rolls be suspended immediately and all 133 million deleted voters restored; that India return to paper ballots in all elections; and that assembly elections held in the past two years "in which conclusive evidence of vote chori has been presented" be repealed. Vote chori means vote theft. The President has no power to remove a chief election commissioner at her own discretion. Under the constitution the post can be vacated only through the procedure used to remove a Supreme Court judge, which requires a parliamentary majority the opposition does not have. सबसे पहले हिंदुस्तान के ...

BJP Calls Bypoll Results Democracy's Reply To Mob Rule And Turns On Rahul Gandhi

Image
The BJP used a day of by-election counting on Friday to mount a sustained attack on Rahul Gandhi, with its national general secretary Smriti Irani describing the results as democracy's reply to what she called mob rule Representational Image: BJP LiveCast Screengrab The phrase referred to a week of opposition demonstrations in the capital over the revision of electoral rolls, during which the Leader of the Opposition and other MPs were stopped and detained on successive days and at least 25 police cases were registered. Irani listed the seats where the BJP was ahead. In West Bengal the party was leading in Nandigram, which she described as having once been a symbol of left-wing violence and of resistance to industrial development, and in Rejinagar, where she said close to 71 per cent of voters belong to minority communities. In Assam the party was leading in the Nagaon Lok Sabha seat. In Puducherry she welcomed the victory of a candidate of the National Democratic Alliance. Coun...

Delhi Police Say No To Saturday's Protest With Prohibitory Orders In Force

Image
Delhi Police have refused permission for a protest planned at Jantar Mantar on Saturday by the Cockroach Janata Party, and have registered 25 cases connected with a week of demonstrations so far Representational Image Source: @IPSMadhurVerma A joint commissioner of police, Nupur Prasad, said the force received an application on 7 October from the group's co-convenor, Saurabh Das, giving notice of a protest on 10 October over what it described as the accountability of the Chief Election Commissioner. Under the rules governing the site, applications must be submitted at least ten days before the event. The application arrived three days before.  Prasad said permission was also refused because the group had been allowed to protest at Jantar Mantar on an earlier occasion and had not complied with police guidelines or with the undertakings it gave at the time.  She cited the law-and-order situation, public safety and traffic management in the New Delhi district, and said pro...
Loading... Loading IST...
MULTIPOLAR DRIFT
🌍 Global Order TRACKER ON
Loading headlines...

Loading Top Trends...

Backpacking India

Scanning sources...

🔦 Newsroom Feed

    🔗 View Source
    Font Replacer Active