FREE SPEECH: Indian Top Court Slams SIT for ‘Misdirected’ Probe in Ashoka Univ Prof Case, Restores Some Freedoms
The Indian Supreme Court on Wednesday issued a pointed reprimand to the Haryana Police's Special Investigation Team (SIT) for what it termed as an “apparent misdirection” in its handling of the case against Ashoka University professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad , who was arrested in May for social media posts on Operation Sindoor . A bench led by Justices Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi made it clear that the SIT’s job was to evaluate whether Mahmudabad’s posts crossed the legal line — not to mount a digital excavation of his life. Image Source: Mahmudabad on X “Why has the SIT gone off the rails?” the court questioned, adding that seizing his devices — including personal phones — was unwarranted given his cooperation with the probe. The court also took a scalpel to the bail gag order previously imposed, now allowing the professor to post opinions and write freely, with one caveat: no commentary on the case pending against him. In essence, he can critique the moon, write on the Ma...