Book Review: What Happens When a Living Constitution Is Treated as a Monument in Shashi Tharoor’s Underworked Book
✍️ Written by Saket Suman There is a revealing gap between what Our Living Constitution by Shashi Tharoor promises and what it delivers. The promise is commentary but the delivery is amateur recital. Over and over again, the book approaches moments of genuine constitutional consequence only to retreat into reverent summary, as though the mere act of repeating what the Constitution says were itself an act of interpretation. Image Source: Tharoorian on X Let us begin by considering the author’s handling of the Preamble. We are told, and correctly so, that it is “ the soul of the Constitution ,” followed by the full ceremonial recitation of “ JUSTICE, social, economic and political; LIBERTY… EQUALITY… FRATERNITY .” The words are allowed to do all the work but there is really no sustained inquiry into how fraternity was historically the most fragile of these promises, nor how Ambedkar himself warned that political equality without social e...